idle's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Agents Agents Agents]

short but sweet.

Wow, that was surprisingly addictive to watch!

For what it was, the animation was simple, yet nice and effective (I especially liked the sentinel). The sound was good, and the song was catchy without becoming irritating. I think it could have been a little bit better if the loop had been extended, but overall, not bad at all.

I'm looking forward to more quality submissions from you.

Shadow-XII responds:

Thank you! <3

The sentinal, for me, was a fucking cocksucker to animate :(

But it was worth it. :)

But, alas, I finally have my own baby on NG...it's my last too. No more, I tell you!

[Hereticus]

I liked it very much.

Well that was damn cool, forsterbar!

I remember just recently you showed me some of the stuff from the potential sequel, so make it already. We need more, dammit!

As for the Flash itself, the animation and subject matter were both quality. Also, the music fitted the piece really well. My only qualm was it's short length, but what can you do.

Overall, an extremely good submission. Keep up the good work.

forsterbar responds:

Why thank you -idle-. Praise from a man of such high esteem as yourself honours me greatly.
He gets a +2 on "to hit" rolls.

[Stick Vs Human 2]

That was unexpected!

Well, that film definitely surprised me, in a good way. Most of the submissions involving video are fairly average, but I liked this one quite a bit (even if it contained stick figures).

In terms of the actual execution of the film, I thought it was quite well done. Obviously, the filesize severely limits the quality of Flash, but all the visuals were still nice and visible in your work. The sync involving the fighting was pretty decent too, but my only complaint was with some of the sound. I thought this aspect of the film could have been better.

Overall though, an interesting submission here LeoZ. Well done.

LeoZ responds:

Thank you for the review! Not a spelling or grammatical error in sight. NG users take note; flash authors like it when you can spell ;) (I know I’m being a super hypocrite, by the way).

Argh, and you are SO RIGHT about the video filesizes. It's a bloody nightmare, stick V human 3 is currently too big.

[All your Mario .::BS::.]

Average.

That was ok, but nothing great here. I would have given you a worse score, but it DID contain Mario and the All Your Base song, so I guess it wasn't too bad. Plus some of those pictures gave me flashbacks, which was kind of neat. Anyway, there is much room for improvement.

KKSlayer responds:

Gives me flashbacks too.
LOL

[Majin Vegetto: Episode 1]

Better than I expected.

That Flash wasn't too bad at all. I am quite a fan of anime, but not really Dragonball Z. Still, the animation was nice, and the style kept with the whole anime theme. The lip-sync and sound were also good, and I liked some of the effects you had running through the movie. Keep up the good work Ryan.

Majin-Ryan responds:

Thanks, im glade you liked it:)

[Mushroom Dreams]

That was entertaining.

I'm not usually a fan of sprite based work, but that was an exception. I found your submission to be quite trippy, and the music choice was great. For sprites, the graphics were done well, and I think the overall theme of the Flash worked nicely. Keep up the good work, Sub-Zedox.

Sub-Zedox responds:

Thank you very much.

[Nazis In Our Days]

I never know what to put here.

Hmmm, that was a simple little Flash, xxSHIFTxx, but good nonetheless. The animation was average, and the sound was ok. The subject matter, however, did give me a laugh and this made up for some of the other areas where it was lacking. Overall, not bad at all. Keep up the good work.

xxSHIFTxx responds:

Thanks

[poopycock]

Not too bad at all.

I actually found that to be very funny, even though it was all a bit cluttered and hectic. I loved the Harvey Birdman character, and there was quite alot of style in this little film. Keep up the good work.

tacotacotaco responds:

right on dude. thanks.

[(OLD) Fight!!! (clay)]

Unimpressive at best.

I'm afraid that was just a poor rip-off of knox's work, and he is by no means original anyway. If you are ging to submit claymation, at least try and come up with some new ideas. In terms of the actual animation, it was fairly well done, for a simple scene. I found the set and characters boring and dull, so improvent in these areas would greatly increase you score. Also, something like this needs to be longer. The ending was slightly funny, but only because I recognised some of the toy weapons. Nostalgia aside, I think you can do alot better next time.

buddy14 responds:

well thanks for leaveing a long comment and all.. But im not copying knox...
Lots of people make clay Animations i just happen to be one of them and I really like makeing them. And yes i will try and come up with new ideas thanks for the tip..